Know your Rights

Know your Rights

Recently we published a polling question over on Facebook: Can an officer demand you provide them with identification?

Five possible answers:

Yes, anytime, anywhere, for any reason.

Yes, but only if you're driving or committing a crime.

Yes, but only if you're committing a crime.

Yes, but only if they think you did something wrong.

No

There was a high turn out for the voting.  Unfortunately, the vast majority of answers were wrong.  It's important that people know what their rights are, and that they exercise their rights.  Before we get into the answers I feel that we should give some reasoning for the answers. The primary two cases relied upon for this answer are:

Hiibel v. Sixth Judicial Dist. Court of Nevada, Humboldt County 542 U.S. 177: Mr. Hiibel was arrested for failing to offer identification. The arrest was held to be constitutional because the request for identification was “reasonably related in scope to the circumstances which justified” the stop. The officer's request was a commonsense inquiry, not an effort to obtain an arrest for failure to identify after a Terry stop yielded insufficient evidence. The stop, the request, and the State's requirement of a response did not contravene the guarantees of the Fourth Amendment, nor did it violate Mr. Hiibel's Fifth Amendment rights. (Keep in mind that while this was Nevada law, it was a US Constitutional interpretation by the Supreme Court, Minnesota Constitution may grant us more protection - but probably not)

Kedzior v. County of Hennepin 1991 WL 53972: This was an older case, but here Mr. Kedzior was suspected of staking a place out for a "smash & grab" over in Richfield. The officer had a valid reason to stop him, and asked for identification under a city identification ordinance. Failure to provide the identification got him charged.

Now for the good stuff - the analysis. To my knowledge and based on all research at this time - Minnesota does not have a "stop and identify" statute. But many cities in Minnesota do. Therefore, unless you know for sure, it's best to assume that the city you are in has such an ordinance. In order for the officer to demand identification and be entitled to identification, they must (according to case law) have a reasonable and articulable basis for such a demand. Here is where one of the problems comes in. Officers don't need to tell you that they have a reason to demand your identification.

So...

1) Yes, anytime, anywhere, for any reason: is incorrect because they do have to have a reason - but they don't have to tell you (if someone was charged without knowing that the officer had a reason, they have a pretty good defense - but that's another issue)

2) Yes, but only if you're driving or committing a crime: is incorrect, officers cannot ask for your identification simply because you are driving a vehicle - they have to have a reason.

3) Yes, but only if you are committing a crime: is incorrect, because you don't have to have committed a crime, the officer simply has to have a reasonable and articulable suspicion that you committed a crime (or are attempting to do so)

5) No: is wrong, because most cities have a "stop and identify" city ordinance, and if the officer has a reason, they can demand identification - in most applications a good attorney can probably convince the judge this is the right answer, but that's not what we asked.

4) Yes, but only if they think you did something wrong: Is the technical and correct answer. The officer has to have a reasonable articulable suspicion.

Please keep in mind - as with all legal arguments that there are always exceptions and exemptions to every rule.


12 comments (Add your own)

1. wrote:
Hi. I see that you don't update your blog too often. I
know that writing articles is boring and time consuming. But did you know that there is a tool that allows
you to create new posts using existing content (from article directories or other
websites from your niche)? And it does it very well. The new articles are
unique and pass the copyscape test. You should try miftolo's tools

Thu, August 2, 2018 @ 7:10 AM

2. wrote:
I can see that your site probably doesn't have much visits.
Your posts are awesome, you only need more new visitors.
I know a method that can cause a viral effect on your
blog. Search in google: dracko's tricks make your content go viral

Sun, August 5, 2018 @ 10:23 PM

3. wrote:
Hi there mates, how is everything, and what you desire to
say concerning this article, in my view its actually amazing in favor of me.

Wed, December 5, 2018 @ 2:47 AM

4. wrote:
It is in reality a great and helpful piece of info.
I'm satisfied that you simply shared this useful information with
us. Please keep us up to date like this.
Thanks for sharing.

Mon, June 3, 2019 @ 11:52 AM

5. wrote:
I used to be recommended this web site by means of my cousin. I'm now not positive whether or not this publish is written by him as no
one else know such distinct about my problem. You are amazing!
Thank you!

Mon, July 8, 2019 @ 9:53 PM

6. wrote:
I am sure this piece of writing has touched all the internet people,
its really really nice post on building up new blog.

Mon, September 23, 2019 @ 10:35 PM

7. wrote:
I'm really impressed with your writing skills as well
as with the layout on your blog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself?
Either way keep up the excellent quality writing, it is rare to
see a nice blog like this one these days.

Mon, September 23, 2019 @ 10:37 PM

8. wrote:
I will right away take hold of your rss feed as I can not in finding your email subscription link or e-newsletter service.

Do you've any? Kindly allow me understand so that I may subscribe.
Thanks.

Wed, September 25, 2019 @ 7:54 AM

9. wrote:
Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all of us you
really recognize what you're speaking about!
Bookmarked. Kindly additionally seek advice from my site =).
We may have a link change arrangement between us

Thu, October 3, 2019 @ 5:32 PM

10. wrote:
If you desire to grow your knowledge only keep visiting this web page and be updated with the hottest gossip posted here.

Tue, October 8, 2019 @ 10:06 PM

11. wrote:
Howdy superb website! Does running a blog such as this require a large amount of work?
I have virtually no knowledge of programming but I had been hoping to start my own blog soon. Anyhow, if you
have any suggestions or techniques for new
blog owners please share. I understand this is off subject nevertheless I simply had to ask.
Thank you!

Fri, October 11, 2019 @ 8:29 AM

12. wrote:
Hello. Do you allow guest posts on aschemanlaw.com ?

Sat, November 9, 2019 @ 8:44 AM

Add a New Comment


code
 

Comment Guidelines: No HTML is allowed. Off-topic or inappropriate comments will be edited or deleted. Thanks.